The hazards of Confidential Information rules in the workplace: study

David Hannah, Associate Professor at the Beedie School of Business.

New research from Simon Fraser University’s Beedie School of Business reveals that organizations that implement rules governing Confidential Information (CI) can make it difficult for employees to fulfill their roles – resulting in rule breaking or bending.

The paper, “Why and How Do Employees Break and Bend Confidential Information Protection Rules?” was co-authored by Beedie Associate Professor David Hannah and Kirsten Robertson, Assistant Professor at the University of the Fraser Valley. It was published in May by the Journal of Management Studies.

The study examined two high-tech organizations that enforce CI protection rules. It found that these rules sometimes proved to be restrictive for employees, forcing them to choose between rule compliance and working efficiently.

Employees were often required to break the rules in order to carry out their jobs effectively, or bend them in ways that enabled them to meet some rule requirements.

“Many organizations rely on CI – the formula for Coca Cola, for example – which they must entrust to employees to allow them to do their jobs,” says Hannah.

“Yet as soon as employees know this CI they become a potential vulnerability, forcing organizations to put in place rules to protect their CI that employees must follow.”

The researchers found that by implementing CI rules they can create three types of tension among employees: obstruction tension, making it difficult for people to work; knowledge network tension, disrupting information flow in personal networks; and identity tension, where employees cannot fulfill the role with which they identify.

Furthermore, the researchers found that employees react to these types of tension by breaking or bending the rules in specific ways: shortcutting, circumventing rules that slowed work; conspiring, where they work together to get around rules; and selectively disclosing, where they allow external networks access to certain aspects of the CI.

“It was reported recently that Apple put new constraints on engineers, prohibiting them from taking prototypes off campus,” says Hannah.

“This is a great example of this sort of tension – the engineers now feel they cannot do their jobs properly because they cannot field test their products.”

In order to ensure employees follow the rules, the researchers recommend that organizations improve communication, explaining satisfactorily why rules are in place.